The Broken Promise of Meritocracy in College Admissions

For decades, Ivy League admissions have been seen as the gateway to success, selecting the best and brightest through a rigorous, merit-based system. Recent developments, such as Harvard’s free tuition policy for all families making less than $200,000/year, are certainly creating a tidal wave of change within the larger academic community regarding accessibility for all students. But David Brooks' The Atlantic article, How Ivy League Admissions Broke America, challenges the persisting narrative that overshadows the typical journey to these actual institutions, arguing that the system now serves as a barrier rather than a bridge to social mobility.

Key Insights

🔹 From Privilege to Meritocracy—Then Back Again
In the early 20th century, elite universities shifted from an aristocratic system favoring legacy admissions to one prioritizing academic achievement. Standardized testing and GPA became the dominant measures of merit. However, today’s process still favors wealth—elite institutions disproportionately admit students from high-income families, reinforcing social divides.

🔹 The Overvaluation of Intelligence
The belief that test scores and grades are the best predictors of success has led to an education system that prizes intelligence over qualities like curiosity, leadership, and resilience. Research suggests that while high IQ correlates with achievement, it doesn’t guarantee impact or innovation. There is also the increasing phenomenon of grade inflation that is interfering with actual learning.

🔹 An Unhealthy Obsession with Status
College admissions have fueled a culture where children are molded into “perfect applicants” from an early age, limiting exploration and creativity. Parents invest heavily in tutoring, extracurriculars, and private schools, turning college acceptance into a high-stakes competition that favors the wealthy.

🔹 A Narrow Definition of Success
Elite universities increasingly serve as pipelines to finance and consulting rather than fostering leaders in public service, science, or the arts. Brooks argues that meritocracy, rather than creating a well-rounded leadership class, has bred risk-averse individuals focused on personal gain.

🔹 Rethinking Merit
Brooks suggests redefining merit to include curiosity, emotional intelligence, adaptability, and social impact—qualities that are harder to quantify but essential for meaningful contributions to society.

The Vault Prep Perspective

At Vault Prep, we understand the complexities of college admissions and the limitations of the current system. Our approach goes beyond test scores and applications—we help students develop intellectual curiosity, critical thinking, and leadership skills that will serve them well beyond college while getting awesome scores that reflect their actual intellect to boot

Rather than playing into the status-obsessed admissions game, we guide students to craft authentic narratives that highlight their unique strengths. Success isn’t just about where you go—it’s about what you do once you get there.

‍